Cartoon for December 28, 2009

The Web just can't keep you warm at night.

Editor believes editorial cartoons are for amusement only

Hi, I'm Stephanie McMillan, creator of the comic strip "Minimum Security" and the editorial cartoon "Code Green" (you can check them out at stephaniemcmillan.org).

Ted has invited me to contribute to his blog. Thank you Ted! Here's my first entry:

Editor & Publisher has an article about some people protesting an offensive cartoon. That's great -- I love protests against offensive things.

But this sentence gave me the chills:

"Newsday issued a statement saying,'we expect the cartoons we publish, many of which are nationally syndicated, to amuse, stir and entertain, but never to offend'."

Wow. What an extraordinary, horrifying statement. I loathe the cartoon, but that's not the point -- this statement makes it clear that the trend toward blandifying papers has not only not slowed, but that editors freely admit that they're okay with it. They're afraid of their readers and afraid of editorializing. This fear of offending anyone is stultifying and so dangerous. Does anyone still think we live in a free society?

I think that as the economic, environmental and other crises increasingly worsen, Americans will become more polarized (that's already happening) and will demand sharper opinions in all areas of the culture. We see the success of those who start to speak out more openly on tv and online. I hope newspaper editors start to understand this emerging trend and figure out that their readers want controversy and strong opinions, not bland meaninglessness.

The whole *purpose* of editorial cartoons is to enlighten, expose, inspire and offend! NOT to "amuse and entertain." Those are secondary. As Mike Lester (a cartoonist who often seriously offends me) correctly stated, non-offensive cartoons "are called greeting cards."

Cartoon for April 9, 2009

Got the idea for this one when I went to buy a newspaper and it was so light that I thought someone had filched a section.

Cartoon for October 13

The New York Times, along with other newspapers, continues its painful process of charging more and delivering less to its readers.